Rule Suggestion Make crouching solely against 076 against the rules

[Illidan Cyplenkov]

What does this suggestion change/add/remove:
Changes/enforces the hitbox abuse rule so that crouching solely for 076 is deemed as hitbox abuse.

Has something similar been suggested before? If so, why is your suggestion different?:
Not that I know

Possible Positives of the suggestion (At least 2):
- Makes combat more realistic
- Gives 076 a fairer chance when attacking
- Makes new 076 players not leave the server because the SWEP is bad

Possible Negatives of the suggestion:
- You die sooner to 076

Based on the Positives & Negatives, why should this suggestion be accepted:
Having people crouch when fighting an SCP with a sword is unrealistic, it's unfair for 076, and doesn't fit the realism that the server strives for.

 

[fiski69]

+Support
Either this or make 076's sword swep hitbox bigger like 682 or 939

 

[Mishashi]

- Gives 076 a fairer chance when attacking

076 has;
a big, quick to swing sword
a massive amount of health
super speed

we have
pew pew gun
armor

 

[Painter]

-support

I will depict my minus support using British Line Infantry.

British Officer : Make Ready!

*The British Infantry slide into formation, the front crouching, the rear leaning right, and the center staying at attention, all with rifles still shouldered and pointed to the sky. *

British Officer : Present!

*The British infantry column readies their weapons and takes aim at the crouching man right in front of them, they would charge like the Japanese or SCP-076 with their bayonets, but that would be out of line.*

British Officer : Fire!

*The British infantry column discharge their flintlocks at the sole GENSEC crouching in front of them and…..miss.*

British Infantry Column : (in union) Hell! I could have sworn we were sighted in for the correct distance!

British Officer : Prime and Load!

*The line infantry being the 3 minute process of reloading their muskets.*

You see, this relates to 076 cause of you miss one swing you can just swing again it will hit them. You arn’t using a flintlock, you can crouch yourself or just look down and you can hit them easily.

 

["Ghost"]

-Support
/me ducks under SCP-076-2s Large Horizontal Swings\

Next it'll be no staring at 173

 

[Boris Johnson]

+Support

The only reason people crouch is because the hits don't register, meaning it takes longer, which makes no sense if this were real life.

 

[Illidan Cyplenkov]

Amusing how everyone who -supports the proposal responds with an unserious babble of text. Textbook example of cognitive dissonance.

Waiting for someone to post actual arguments

 

[fiski69]

+Support

The only reason people crouch is because the hits don't register, meaning it takes longer, which makes no sense if this were real life.

This is the whole point pretty much. People crouch because they know 076's sword can't hit them if they do it. Literally just hitbox abuse

 

[fiski69]

-support

I will depict my minus support using British Line Infantry.

British Officer : Make Ready!

*The British Infantry slide into formation, the front crouching, the rear leaning right, and the center staying at attention, all with rifles still shouldered and pointed to the sky. *

British Officer : Present!

*The British infantry column readies their weapons and takes aim at the crouching man right in front of them, they would charge like the Japanese or SCP-076 with their bayonets, but that would be out of line.*

British Officer : Fire!

*The British infantry column discharge their flintlocks at the sole GENSEC crouching in front of them and…..miss.*

British Officer : Prime and Load!

*The line infantry being the 3 minute process of reloading their muskets.*

You see, this relates to 076 cause of you miss one swing you can just swing again it will hit them. You arn’t using a flintlock, you can crouch yourself or just look down and you can hit them easily.

??

 

[fiski69]

-Support
/me ducks under SCP-076-2s Large Horizontal Swings\

Next it'll be no staring at 173

gives no arguments but just gives a idiotic strawman lol

 

[Ganch]

This is the whole point pretty much. People crouch because they know 076's sword can't hit them of they do it. Literally just hitbox abuse

ok so if u crouch to dodge a bullet its hitbox abusing got it

-support

unnecessary to buff 076, a SCP which is doing completely fine. If you cant hit a crouching target? idk just pull your mouse down its that shrimple, feels like you only made this suggestion because a guy could avoid being killed for 3 seconds because he could press control on his keyboard

How do you expect staff to enforce this? haha ur crouching to do a firing line with 2 different lines, 1 at front 1 at back to kill a SCP, oh no 076 comes everyone has to uncrouch!! A person crouches while fighting 076, 076 screams "HITBOX ABUSE HITBOX ABUSE HITBOX ABUSE" breaking immersion within RP, which means your suggestion to "improve RP" is invalid in that situation

its also just dumb, forcing people to not crouch while fighting 076? unnecessary addition to the rules for everyone to read, will get people warned unnecessarily

 

[fiski69]

ok so if u crouch to dodge a bullet its hitbox abusing got it

-support

unnecessary to buff 076, a SCP which is doing completely fine. If you cant hit a crouching target? idk just pull your mouse down its that shrimple, feels like you only made this suggestion because a guy could avoid being killed for 3 seconds because he could press control on his keyboard

How do you expect staff to enforce this? haha ur crouching to do a firing line with 2 different lines, 1 at front 1 at back to kill a SCP, oh no 076 comes everyone has to uncrouch!! A person crouches while fighting 076, 076 screams "HITBOX ABUSE HITBOX ABUSE HITBOX ABUSE" breaking immersion within RP, which means your suggestion to "improve RP" is invalid in that situation

its also just dumb, forcing people to not crouch while fighting 076? unnecessary addition to the rules for everyone to read, will get people warned unnecessarily

crouching for 10 seconds against a melee range scp is not comparible to dodging a bullet,but you knew that already

 

[Zen]

-Support
Just look down or crouch. This isn't hitbox abuse, you're just stupid. Having to slow down for a couple of seconds to actually put in a slight amount of effort to hit someone isn't a problem, that's just gameplay. Just because you can't just run around spam clicking (you have to turn your head or crouch like some kind of commoner now and then) doesn't mean people are cheating.

 

[Archangel]

-support

 

[ZLT49A]

Honestly walking and breathing should be against the rules too while were at it. And maybe joining the server should be fail RP because you wouldn't connect to a gmod server as a member of the SCP foundation.

 

[Biscuits]

just look down

 

[Painter]

Amusing how everyone who -supports the proposal responds with an unserious babble of text. Textbook example of cognitive dissonance.

Waiting for someone to post actual arguments

Why so blind? My argument was if you look down you can hit them. This is a cope suggestion lad. Can’t aim with sword. Maybe read the whole thing next time instead of trying to personally attack people who don’t agree with you.?

 

[Drxgon]

- support

how is crouching in game any different than someone dodging a sword swing? people used to dodge swords all the time, so i dont see how this is an issue. 076 just has to look down and swing when the crouch aka they dodge

 

[Ganch]

crouching for 10 seconds against a melee range scp is not comparible to dodging a bullet,but you knew that already

its fine you ignore the rest of my points and just say "but uhmm uhhh 10 seconds haha"

just look down, if they crouch for 10 seconds they are very immobile and you kill them so your point is just invalid

 

[Prplex]

-Support
Can be fixed by crouching or looking down at your target and makes 076 attacking less mindless other than that lots of people crouch when firing at stuff whether that be in a firing line or what