Denied Change 22415-1s heal ability with necromancy ability

This suggestion has been denied and will not receive development.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Oct 31, 2022
22
1
111
What does this suggestion change/add/remove:
This suggestion brings up the idea of changing 22415's healing ability with the (as far as I know) necromancy ability that thaums have. The reason I recommend this is that 22415-1 already has a med kit that can heal just as well the healing ability with the cost of losing power. Adding with the fact that it would take more power to tp someone to your dimension and then use the healing power when you can just instead tp someone to your dimension and heal them with the med kit.

This would simply be swapping the heal ability for the necromancy one, with the added balance of having it cost anywhere from 75-100 power, have a cooldown of 1-2 minutes and if really needed only be allowed to revive 1-2 people at a time.

Has something similar been suggested before? If so, why is your suggestion different?:
To my knowledge of scrolling through all resolved and on going threads with the keywords 22415. I can say no other person has brought up the idea.

Possible Positives of the suggestion (At least 2):
  • Revival of personnel that medics can't get to
  • The ability to get revived players to safety soon after
  • Be able to assist researchers in tests that may have other personnel killed during testing.

Possible Negatives of the suggestion:
  1. One of the negatives of such a change may be due to the removal of the risk factor that medics take during revivals
    • Because of this they may deem it unfair as someone they just killed can just come back without them being able to do anything if not prepared.
  2. The second negative may be that medical personnel would have to somewhat fight with 22415-1 in who can revive who faster
    • Because of this lower class medical may begin to dislike 22415-1 as they would be missing out on some of the XP that reviving brings.
Based on the Positives & Negatives, why should this suggestion be accepted:
Well as said in the first questions I think that the healing ability is redundant due to 22415-1 already having a med kit and do believe that being able to revive at least 1 player can prove beneficial to 22415-1s gameplay loop. Even with the negatives that may come by I think these negatives would become more acceptable once people get used to it and understand the said change onto 22415-1. Due to my lack of knowledge of server changes I can't say if this would be an easy or hard change but do believe it should be done.
 
...How to give CI a heart attack - I believe there's already enough concern with Thaums potentially inappropriately reviving raiding parties (CI/GOC) when they generally shouldn't be allowed for balance purposes - Although 22415 is different in that it's a whitelisted role behind an app. I guess it could work with adjustment to the app, but then there's concerns with everyone that already has the whitelist that I don't know a general announcement would be enough to alleviate.

I don't think that's the full reason why this might be denied, but I feel that's a contributing factor. I personally have no particular opinions on the matter. I don't feel strongly about this in any direction. If it works, it works. If it doesn't work, it doesn't work.
+/- Neutral
 
May 27, 2023
46
6
111
-support
this can get abuse by both foundation player who have the job and CI player who have the job
most confusing - support since 22415 wouldnt help ci most of the time (due to their morally incorrect actions) and if they did it would be classed as a fail rp and /or teaming alongside every scp can be abused
 

James Dingle

Administrator
Administrator
SCP-RP Staff
Content Team
Jul 13, 2024
166
62
41
Suggestion Denied



Hi @Fellowchum ,

Thanks for taking the time to make a server suggestion.

The Content Team has chosen to deny your suggestion due to the following reason(s):

Content Team feel that the current healing ability of SCP-22415-1 is perfectly fine and is helpful within the server landscape.

Necromancy also has a small chance of turning someone into a zombie or decaying person upon revival, which doesn't really fit in with SCP-22415-1's lore being that they cannot ' ...commit or assist anything considered "immoral" ' or ' directly assist in the harm of any living thing ' which the above states would contribue towards.

Your suggestion will now be locked and marked as denied.​
 
Status
Not open for further replies.