Bobby1 Staff Demotion Appeal

Status
Not open for further replies.
Bobby1

Bobby1

Moderator
Moderator
One Year Club Two Year Club Three Year Club Conversation Starter
Jan 8, 2021
331
56
111
Name: Bobby
Steam ID: STEAM_0:0:91861058
Previous Rank (convert if required): Moderator
Who demoted you?: Alex/NL
Date of demotion?: Earlier this year
What is the case against you?: Abuse of staff permissions
Is this true?: Yes
Prior to this demotion, have you ever been demoted?: Yes, in 2021/22
Have you ever been kicked/warned/banned?: Yes
What is your side of the story?: I was burnt out from playing the server WAY to much and I wanted an easy way out, instead of just telling the current SL at the time I was wanting to leave, I made the stupid decision to MRDM and get banned.
Why should you return / what will you change?: I have already been trusted with staff permissions since then as I was GM but I left on my own terms as I did not enjoy running events as much as I used to.
 
Harry

Harry

Civil Gamers Expert
Mapping Team
One Year Club Two Year Club Three Year Club Conversation Starter
Aug 28, 2021
183
44
111
+Support

Hi Bobby, I don’t respond to things like this very often tbh as I’m not very prevalent within the staff side of the community but saw this and felt compelled to reply to share my opinions.


Bobby, although his previously controversial and rocky history within the community, has recently become an apparent and good member within the MRP community. I’ve generally seen him improve his conduct and compliance with the rules much further than he has in his past. I believe this development should not be overlooked at all and should assist in accepting this appeal.

You can see this change in character via the determination and passion he had recently as TGM (Now resigned for this appeal). Although he began to lack motivation after a rough patch of events and scenarios (who wouldn’t) he made the mature choice that TGM wasn’t for him and served his 1 week following all appropriate procedures for it. This sheer change in character should be more than enough to forgive him for his prior incidents and prove that he has changed more than enough to be given another chance within the staff team (just in a different sector of it this time).

I heavily believe and recommend and SSL reading this to accept his application and allow someone to prove that they’ve changed which Bobby clearly has.

Good Luck Bobby,
Harry
 
YaBoi

YaBoi

Civil Gamers Expert
One Year Club Two Year Club Three Year Club
Apr 11, 2021
68
21
111
+Support

I fully support Bobby's application for reinstatement as a Moderator, and here are the reasons why:
  1. Accountability and Honesty:
    Bobby has shown a commendable level of honesty in admitting to his past mistakes, including the misuse of staff permissions and the actions that led to his demotion. This transparency demonstrates his willingness to take responsibility, a key trait for someone in a leadership or moderation role.
  2. Evidence of Growth:
    Since the incident, Bobby has held another staff position as GM, where he was entrusted with permissions and responsibilities. Importantly, he left that position on his own terms, showing maturity and self-awareness rather than resorting to disruptive behavior as in the past.
  3. Understanding of Past Mistakes:
    Bobby acknowledges that burnout contributed to his poor decision-making. His awareness of this issue suggests he has reflected on how to better handle similar situations in the future. Recognizing and addressing personal challenges is critical for avoiding repeated mistakes.
  4. Experience and Dedication:
    Bobby has demonstrated a strong commitment to the server in the past, albeit to the point of burnout. His prior experience as both a Moderator and GM means he is already familiar with the rules, culture, and expectations, which minimizes the learning curve for reinstatement.
  5. Potential for a Positive Impact:
    By returning to the team, Bobby has the chance to use his past experiences to mentor others, model accountability, and contribute positively to the community. His history of growth and improvement suggests he can become an even stronger asset to the staff team.
Everyone makes mistakes, and Bobby has demonstrated that he is capable of learning from his. By showing honesty, growth, and a renewed commitment to the community, he has earned another chance to prove himself. For these reasons, I believe Bobby deserves the opportunity to return as a Moderator.
 
Harold Hawks

Harold Hawks

Civil Gamers Expert
One Year Club Conversation Starter
Mar 12, 2023
570
1
94
61
America
YaBoi said:
+Support

I fully support Bobby's application for reinstatement as a Moderator, and here are the reasons why:
  1. Accountability and Honesty:
    Bobby has shown a commendable level of honesty in admitting to his past mistakes, including the misuse of staff permissions and the actions that led to his demotion. This transparency demonstrates his willingness to take responsibility, a key trait for someone in a leadership or moderation role.
  2. Evidence of Growth:
    Since the incident, Bobby has held another staff position as GM, where he was entrusted with permissions and responsibilities. Importantly, he left that position on his own terms, showing maturity and self-awareness rather than resorting to disruptive behavior as in the past.
  3. Understanding of Past Mistakes:
    Bobby acknowledges that burnout contributed to his poor decision-making. His awareness of this issue suggests he has reflected on how to better handle similar situations in the future. Recognizing and addressing personal challenges is critical for avoiding repeated mistakes.
  4. Experience and Dedication:
    Bobby has demonstrated a strong commitment to the server in the past, albeit to the point of burnout. His prior experience as both a Moderator and GM means he is already familiar with the rules, culture, and expectations, which minimizes the learning curve for reinstatement.
  5. Potential for a Positive Impact:
    By returning to the team, Bobby has the chance to use his past experiences to mentor others, model accountability, and contribute positively to the community. His history of growth and improvement suggests he can become an even stronger asset to the staff team.
Everyone makes mistakes, and Bobby has demonstrated that he is capable of learning from his. By showing honesty, growth, and a renewed commitment to the community, he has earned another chance to prove himself. For these reasons, I believe Bobby deserves the opportunity to return as a Moderator.
Click to expand...
1732894862307.png
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom