Denied F-GOC F-CI CI-GOC Actual secure comms

[Thorn]

What does this suggestion change/add/remove:
This suggestion would add actual secure comms between each faction in the server it would new /c comms
- Commands would be
/F-CI
/F-GOC
/GOC-CI

Has something similar been suggested before? If so, why is your suggestion different?:
I do not believe this suggestion has been done before since we just do /oc (F-CI) etc...

Possible Positives of the suggestion (At least 2):
This would just be a small change we could use between factions the main thing this would prevent would be
- No metagaming from seeing the Open comms OOC cause if you see something even if you don't actually do something you can't see it in character it will still affect your judgment and this would prevent that

Possible Negatives of the suggestion:
There are no negatives to this suggestion

Based on the Positives & Negatives, why should this suggestion be accepted:
I think this should be added because it would prevent Metagaming more and would make it easier to work with one of the factions without the other one "knowing" (even if its OOC) what you and the other one are talking about

 

[Chad]

+support

 

[Playdoughzombie]

+Massive Support
Id make it only available to like cl4, SOP, and Ethics/05 on foundations side but yes, I agree with this 100%

 

[Mozzie]

+support

 

[Ender]

+Support ​

now there would not be much meta-gaming

 

[Garry]

+Support
Finally a good suggestion

 

[John "Kratos" Freeman]

+support
I see this as a win win

 

[Betriv]

-support
i wanna see the beef

 

[Rowling]

i wanna see the beef

ong

 

[Max Henry]

+Support

 

[Moxxie]

+Support

but now i cant read other ppls drama when im bored on civi

 

[Bill Nye The Guy]

-support makes chat feel more dead
here's a few negatives not mentioned in the suggestion (made a comment later that explains these in more detail):

Ruins existing RP on OC
Makes OC completely unnecessary outside of events and minges on surface
New players will see a dead chat and get a bad impression of the server
Makes RP harder on OC, especially for events
Makes chat feel dead (key example here is Foundation comms now that all regiments can speak to each other)
Suggestion fails to mention who will get access to secure comms
Makes anybody trying to RP on their own look silly and discourages them from doing so

 

[Second]

+/- A good idea in concept but I like reading the twitter drama that is O-Comms, also which jobs on Foundation would have it? I'd hope only A-1, O-1, Nu-7, DEA, SA, Assistants, and SC, right?

 

[socalphunk]

+support

 

[Nohacks]

-1 keeps chat going and active and we get to laugh at funny commets to each factions

 

[KingViper115]

+Massive Support
-this needs to be a thing to prevent any hidden metagaming that happens between all 3 factions
-it also introduces element of surprises if lets say goc and ci agree to attack foundation together (not gonna happen but just an example)

i could type more about this but you get the point.

 

[Bob "Gustav" Smith]

Huge - Support
we must see the beef

 

[Mitski]

+ Support

But if this is implemented, O-Comms would be kind of useless, civs would only be using it

 

[Billy Boy]

im conflicted, on one hand it makes sense to stop metagaming
on the other hand o-comms is funny to read

 

[Biscuits]

+Support
If you wanted to have a comedic conversation with another faction open comms can still be used, simple as.