Denied replacement of the a2 abrams for the Leclerc Série 2 [17THAR suggestion voted and had meeting over]

[Alpha rest]

What does this suggestion change/add/remove?The suggestion proposes adding the Leclerc S2 tank model to replace the A2 Abrams. if implemented you would have to add a minigun to the 3rd seat

Steam Workshop::[simfphys] Leclerc Série 2

steamcommunity.com

Has something similar been suggested before? If so, why is your suggestion different?No, there hasn't been a similar suggestion previously.

Possible Positives of the suggestion (At least 2):

• Improved Handling and Stability: The Leclerc S2 could address the problematic handling and shaky cannon issues associated with the A2 Abrams, providing a significant advantage.
• Easier to Operate: As a counterpart to the T-90, the Leclerc S2 might be easier to gun and drive, leveling the playing field.

Possible Negatives of the suggestion:Adding the Leclerc S2 may contribute to the current development workload. While I understand that I might be the only one voicing concerns about tanks, this issue is widespread among the 17th Armored Regiment. Conversations with experienced SNCO+ personnel and even former 1st Armored members support this view.
Based on the Positives & Negatives, why should this suggestion be accepted?Implementing the Leclerc S2 would give our competitor to the T-90 a fighting chance in the already uphill battle.

 

[Otters]

=/= Neutral

Im not a believer of either replacing/buffing a tank to solve the issue.

 

[TailSkipper]

+support
- a2 handling is horrible super hard to fire while driving
-tank looks dope

 

[Kanser]

+Support
-A2 handling is shaky and weird
-more variety of nato tanks
-The tank looks good
-could be easier to implement since it already has a simfphys of it

 

[Alpha rest]

+Support
-A2 handling is shaky
-more variety of nato tanks
-The tank looks good
-could be easier to implement
-the bones on the tracks look and feel like it will solve the issue
the suggestion may be posted my be but it wasnt me who broght the idea to light so this is my personal +support im not trying to make the post look better

 

[parker]

+support
Very shaky,
Easy to implement probably

 

[Bobby1]

+support
+Has been ages since 17th got a new tank
+A2 always been terrible imo
+New tank for moka to steal

 

[Zhorik.]

+Support
+New Tank for 17th
+Levels Playing field
-3rd Seat gun needs implementation
Despite it needing a 3rd seat gun to be implemented, I am all for this change.

 

[Nirvan]

+Support
Instead of adding new tanks, I think replacing the whole vehicle system is way better but since There's no dev work done on MRP this should be a quick fix for the A2 problem.
French tank tho

 

[Vladislav]

VIVE LA FRANCE VIVE LA FRANCE VIVE LA FRANCE VIVE LA FRANCE VIVE LA FRANCE VIVE LA FRANCE VIVE LA FRANCE VIVE LA FRANCE VIVE LA FRANCE VIVE LA FRANCE VIVE LA FRANCE VIVE LA FRANCE VIVE LA FRANCE VIVE LA FRANCE VIVE LA FRANCE VIVE LA FRANCE VIVE LA FRANCE VIVE LA FRANCE VIVE LA FRANCE VIVE LA FRANCE VIVE LA FRANCE VIVE LA FRANCE VIVE LA FRANCE VIVE LA FRANCE VIVE LA FRANCE VIVE LA FRANCE


WHAT IS A GOOD TANK?????????


( i doubt it will get accepted due to more than likely cost related issues since people are greedy but +support)

 

[drako dormus]

neutral

-support french
that is it

 

[MLGMagicHoodini]

-support
Doubt it will fix the driving and gun handling since I believe these be affected by Tick rate, and not the tank itself, but up to staff to try and see if it's better

 

['James']

Suggestion Denied​

---

Hi Alpha rest, Your suggestion has been denied.

Due to your file size being too large.

Thank you for taking the time to make a suggestion​