Denied SGRU/SAS Demolition kit change.

[MOIST_]

What does this suggestion change/add/remove: Make it so the SAS/SGRU Demolition job spawns on the same life with a stinger and AT4 without needing to die to switch them.

Has something similar been suggested before? If so, why is your suggestion different?: Sep 29, 2022. An suggestion was made for STS / SOTF Demolitions change that STS/SOTF (SAS?) should have a choice between having stinger and demolition and not having both on same life for "Balancing" reasons.

Possible positives of the suggestion (At least 2):

1. Reduces the inconvenience of needing to swap jobs or die constantly to switch to an AT or a stinger due there is a helicopter or a tank/IFV.
2. Reduces accidents while utilizing the Demo kit, for example: You accidentally selected the AT4 Kit while attempting to choose the stinger kit to deal with the helicopter, thus you must now deal with the helicopter with an AT4 till you die.

Possible negatives of the suggestion:
I can see none.

Based on the Positives & Negatives, why should this suggestion be accepted: I simply believe it is an inconvenience to have them as separate kits, and it would be much better for the two regiments if the two kits were combined into one like all other anti-tank or demolition jobs but at the same time there might be a possibility this might be "bit" unbalancing.

 

[Alpha rest]

-support i do understand but this is in place for a reason so it make you think on which aa or at is needed and make it more fair

 

[Kvalax]

Neutral

If one person can hold a stinger AND an AT4, that sounds pretty OP to me. But maybe give 2 slots on demolitions?

 

[MOIST_]

Neutral

If one person can hold a stinger AND an AT4, that sounds pretty OP to me. But maybe give 2 slots on demolitions?

The 2 demo jobs would be useful but I doubt it would get approved either.

 

[Hoxton]

Accepted - STS / SOTF Demolitions change

What does this suggestion change/add/remove: IVG / 15th / 1stAL / JAC Demo job: 2 slots Anti tank and anti air launcher Proxy and C4 STS / SOTF 1 slot Must choose between anti air and anti tank launcher Proxy and C4 CANNOT CHANGE PRIMARY WEAPON I don't think it should be a direct downgrade...

civilnetworks.net

I know a lot of people play this job but personally I've almost never touched it as someone who was a col of the regiment because Its just not worth it in the current state

also I dont know if they done any changes but I THINK the rocket launchers are still trash just like how they used to be and stingers got a slight buff

but like I said in that suggestion I think making it 1 slot instead of 2 AND forcing it to only use 1 launcher is overkill, keep it 1 slot but give it both launchers

 

[Jason M.]

-Support



The only regiments (to my knowledge) that are equipped with both a stinger and an at4 is the 2 slot AT job that 40th/isaf get.
This is due to balancing and the fact that the entire gimmick of the infantry regiments is having more equipment to use against tanks/vehicles.

Giving SAS what 40th/isaf are unique for isn't a good idea in my book.

 

[Aleem Abdul]

Suggestion Denied​

---

Hi Elbart, Your suggestion has been denied.

We believe this would give them too much power, there is currently too much for vehicle regiments to worry about, they do not need more.

Thank you for taking the time to make a suggestion​