Content Suggestion Speaking while bring crushed to death

[Luminary]

What does this suggestion change/add/remove:
Make it so if you are being crushed to death by 8837 you are not able to speak/call out anything in anyway possible (stripp comms or just gag the person while they are being crushed).

Has something similar been suggested before? If so, why is your suggestion different?:
Not that I have seen.

Possible Positives of the suggestion (At least 2):
+Immersion: It is not logical in any way that a human being that is actively being crushed to death is able to speak.
+Fairness: To an SCP, having your position being called out is a huge disadvantage, and the circumstances that E11 and other Combatives do so (in this case being crushed to death) feels like abusing the fact there is nothing stopping them from doing so. I first thought this was powergaming (using an ingame mechanic to your advantage), but it appears that it is not. This is the reason I'm making the suggestion in the first place.

Possible Negatives of the suggestion:
The only real negative I see with this is the fact that people wont be able to call out an scp when they are alone, but to be honest E11 just scout different areas alone and once they find the SCP they just call it out and keep going back to where they died with everyone else and keep damaging the SCP until it's RCd (it happens everytime).

 

[Evan]

+Support

I don’t understand how a person being crushed to death experiencing so much pain would be able to say “8837 CB”.

 

[Emilia Fοddg]

Who downvoted this
+Support
EDIT: Wait why is this a rule suggestion and not a content suggestion, just apply the gag flag to crushing?

 

[Rion]

+Support

Small change but makes sense

 

[Michael Dzhetnikov]

am i allowed to scream in agony

 

[Speff]

-support its funny to hear people scream as theyre dying

 

[Zen]

This would be impossible to enforce as a rule. Make a content suggestion to physically prevent it during that.

 

[bsduser]

+ / - Support

This should be a content suggestion and not a rule one imo

 

[Krennic]

+/- Support
As the others said, this would be better as a content change rather than a rule. But I generally agree with the idea.

 

[werta600]

+Support it would be a nice QoL buff for 8837

 

[Tub]

Imposing this as a rule would be nearly impossible. Just make it so it strips your comms and weapons similar to getting it stripped by other players. I don't think it should just flat out stop you from speaking since some people make it very funny when being crushed.

 

[Luminary]

Changed it from rule suggestion to Content Suggestion.

 

[Zen]

With it now being a content suggestion, I've changed to +Support. Some of these abilities it doesn't make sense and some it does - as long as it's not applied overly broadly, then this makes sense to me.

 

[Areks]

i mean yeah sure it's realistic but since when was realism fun in games?
-support
i also wanna hear people scream its funny

 

[Luminary]

realism fun in games?

Since you are playing in a RP server . Also I find the screaming funny, what I dislike are E11 calmly calling out my location while they are becoming a meatball as if they were not supposed to be in pain.

 

[Areks]

Since you are playing in a RP server

roleplay servers obviously have to allow for realism to an extent, but games are also meant to be fun, this is a trivial change that doesn't neccesarily impact gameplay or roleplay and i personally find it more fun cause i play games for fun and it's funny to hear people scream and make them being crushed to death all dramatic with it, i just find this in specific to be dragging it, yes its realistic but, i dont find it fun

 

[Luminary]

I know, its better to prioritize fun rather than realism. Its just people dont do funny reactions when dying in this context.

 

[Average member podidski]

-support

Let me hear the screams of the poor and damned souls.

 

[Auburn]

why not just force people to scream whatever theyre saying while being crushed? Like hearing someone screaming 8837 down the radio as theyre being crushed would be pretty peak icl

 

[Avery Snow]

Honestly, I like it when those who are being crushed scream out.
-Support