Denied Stop Defibbing to Kidnap

[Generic]

What does this suggestion change/add/remove:
Prevents people from defibrillating dead players to then take hostage.

Possible Positives of the suggestion (At least 2):
Taking hostages shouldn't happen as often as it does, having medics defib the dead and helpless just to take hostage for 15-20 minutes is very annoying. If you engage in a combat situation, you shouldn't expect to be kidnapped after you die. It requires no effort from whoever is taking you hostage and the hostage RP isn't needed as often as it is happening.

Possible Negatives of the suggestion:
Hostage taking is all about money, players do it because of the economy. Hardly ever do they actually interrogate the prisoners.

Based on the Positives & Negatives, why should this suggestion be accepted:
Having this suggestion accepted means that players get to enjoy going out onto surface and not worry for whether after one death they will have to sit in a cell for 20 minutes. People who enjoy combat don't want it interrupted just cause others want money.

Stopping defib hostage taking doesn't stop all hostage taking, it is more realistic for players to put other players under fearrp when taking them hostage as opposed to having to defibrillate dead ones.

 

[Wib Wubbles]

nu7 medic whitelist has a bad loadout

The Nu7 medic loadout is completely fine, the GRY is a great gun. Just hit your shots.

 

[Darren]

gry is literally a beast bro i got that on dclass and slaughtered gensec

 

[SamPaval]

-support

Then kidnapping would be impossible for all sides. Aside from fear rping a DC we wouldnt he able to get any hostages

 

[Monker]

+support mrp does not have defibs but people were still able to kidnap

 

[Sevoio]

-support

Dont die

 

[Landon]

-support
Cope

 

[Moop]

-Support people unfortunately break the rules so trying to fear RP someone is hard and dying for it is even more annoying. When you defib someone you can cuff them before they pull any weapons out which is good.

 

[RoxieCat2003]

-support

 

[Second]

+support, foundation ability to defib v ci is not comparable, nu7 medic whitelist has a bad loadout and combat medics hardly go to surface because they arent part of a regiment

But if Nu-7 and C. Med were to work together on surface that's 10 Medics compared to CI's 4

Also, let's note one thing. Not all CI captures happen on Surface, in fact I'd argue a good chunk happen in-base where even Cl1 trainees can safely revive someone.

Overall, -support on the Suggestion

 

[Skittles]

-Support
Have at least 1 cyanide ready at all times

 

[GMAN0289]

Neutral
Its not a horrible idea. Hostage RP isn't very fun, and taking hostages should be a bigger deal then just reviving people during combat. If the suggestion was accepted there could be another argument made to increase prices for hostages. This would mean it would be rare to capture people, but you can get more money per hostage.

 

[Jules]

Suggestion Denied​

---

Hi @Generic ,

Thanks for taking the time to make a server suggestion.

We will not be adding this as a rule as to be fair what would be the point of having Defibs then on any job if you cannot use them? For the most part it is engaging into the RP or scenario at your own risk. If you are running to go stop a CI raid, then that is one of the risks you just have to face.

Your suggestion will now be locked and marked as denied.

Kindest Regards,
Personnel Lead
Jules​